Saturday, August 3, 2013

Quarterback Power Rankings 2013: 'Good But Not Great' QB Tier


13.      Tony Romo, Dallas Cowboys
Romo’s failures in the fourth quarter have been widely documented, but what goes under the radar has been the constant letdowns of the Cowboys defense. Season after season, the Cowboys defense is comprised of star talent, yet is unable to stop opposing offenses from marching down the field with ease. Romo’s late game turnovers are unacceptable, but to blame him for the Cowboys mediocrity in recent years is just not fair. Romo threw for a career-best 4,903 yards (3rd most in NFL) last season and the year before he posted an incredible TD-INT rate with 31 touchdowns on just 10 interceptions. Alas, Romo needs to do better in clutch situations in order to be considered of the league’s best QB’s.

14.      Matt Schaub, Houston Texans
Schaub is about to enter the most important season of his career. Anything short of reaching the AFC Championship Game would be deemed a failure for the Texans, after losing in the AFC Divisional round in each of the past two seasons. Schaub is a perfect fit in Houston's offensive scheme because of his ability to succeed in the play-action (110 QBR in these types of plays last year). Schaub’s success rate in the play-action is crucial for an offense that centers on running back Arian Foster. The Texans are a Super-Bowl contender, but the million dollar question is can Schaub lead his club to the promise land?

15.      Philip Rivers, San Diego Chargers
The amount of criticism towards Rivers’ play last season baffles me. First off, Rivers tossed 26 touchdowns on 15 interceptions and registered the 11th best passer rating with a mark of 88.6. (better than Joe Flacco, Eli Manning and Cam Newton to name a few). Rivers was able to achieve these feats with the 27th ranked rushing attack, an abysmal offensive line, a banged-up Antonio Gates and with the top receiver on the team being Malcom Floyd. The Chargers woes as a team last season were not indicative of the quarterback play of Rivers. Life will be easier on Rivers with the selections of tackle D.J. Fluker and wide receiver Keenan Allen from this past year’s draft. In order for Rivers to return to his once dominant form (Check out his incredible statistics from seasons 2008-2010), he must become a better decision maker, be a tad more patient in the pocket and hope that the front office reloads the offense with new targets for him to throw to.

16.      Matthew Stafford, Detroit Lions
With Stafford entering his fifth season in the league, it is way too early to write him off as the signal-caller of the future for the Lions franchise, especially given his proven incredulous arm strength. Stafford is one of the league’s best quarterbacks at throwing the deep ball (yes, WR Calvin Johnson drastically helps Stafford’s cause), but struggles when he is not lined up out of the shotgun. Stafford mechanics must be refined and he must cut down on his off-balanced throws. The Lions would be wise to trim down the pass attempts of Stafford, who has tossed the most passes in the league the past two years by far. If the Lions can establish a running game, Stafford could be poised for success—if he sharpens his footwork and accuracy in his throws.

17.      Jay Cutler, Chicago Bears
Cutler had a down season in 2012, but the hope is that the offensive minded new head coach, Marc Trestman, will hone the precision of Cutler’s erratic passes. Cutler is one of the strongest slingers in the game, but often times he tries to fit the ball in too tight of situations. There is upside with Cutler, who brought the Bears to the NFC Championship in 2010. However, the clock is ticking on the former first round pick to take his talents to the next level, particularly with how much this franchise has invested in him financially. 
18.      Cam Newton, Carolina Panthers
After a record-breaking rookie season, Newton entered his second year in the NFL with a cocky and self-assured attitude that grew on the ire not only of analysts, but also of his fellow Panther teammates. Newton was able to mature, though, last season when the losses started to pile up. He finished the season in grand fashion, throwing nine touchdowns with just two interceptions in his final five games, leading the Panthers to four late-season wins. Newton's upside is undeniable as he is one of the most dynamic QB’s in the league with his capacity to beat a defense via the rushing attack and through the air. There should be some anxiety for Carolina fans this season, though, with Panthers GM Dave Gettleman putting unneeded pressure on Newton by asserting that the third-year QB needs to lead the team to more wins this season. Gettleman is putting unfair expectations on Newton and the Panthers, who appear a step behind the other three teams in the ferocious NFC South division.

No comments:

Post a Comment